If you have a proposal on the horizon and want to find a quality-made and stunning ring online, then Etsy engagement rings are hands-down some of the best.
Etsy is a marketplace that allows smaller businesses, like independent jewelers, to market their available goods online. With countless engagement rings available on Etsy, it’s a valuable resource for those who might want to view a variety of different ring styles at once.
Plus, you can likely save a pretty penny on Etsy compared to some of the big jewelry brands that tend to feature exorbitant prices for their engagement rings.
Here at GWS, we’re all about celebrating the special and extraordinary. Etsy boasts tons of unique and often one-of-a-kind-jewels, which is why you’re bound to find a ring that will look fab on that ring finger. From round to pear, simple to stack, boho to vintage, Etsy has some gorgeous options.
That’s why we’ve rounded up some of our all-time favorite Etsy engagement rings so you can choose your favorite band!
Green Wedding Shoe’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. If you would like to support GWS, please consider shopping through our links!
Is it weird to buy an engagement ring on Etsy?
If you’ve found yourself asking if it’s weird to buy an engagement ring on Etsy we have a simple answer for you: Absolutely not!
Listen, online shopping isn’t going anywhere anytime soon and only continues to become more comprehensive. Because of this, many small businesses and jewelry boutiques have taken their inventory and made them available on Etsy. There is a large variety of engagement ring sellers on Etsy, so you’ll never be short of options.
Some engagement rings can get pretty pricey. Luckily, Etsy provides a huge range of different ring options for any budget, so you don’t have to sweat any big-ticket prices. The perfect ring can come from anywhere, and Etsy is no exception.
Plus, when you’re buying from a small business on Etsy, there’s a good chance they’d be willing to customize your engagement ring to your specific preferences, which isn’t always possible with larger ring retailers without a hefty price tag.
Why buy an Etsy engagement ring?
Especially for an online marketplace like Etsy, engagement ring shopping online can simplify the process of visiting countless jewelry stores trying to find the perfect band.
Etsy is convenient because you can browse through different styles based on a search query. Also, Etsy consists of many small businesses and handmade jewelers, so you can trust you’re not throwing money at some huge jeweler. If you’re looking to support small businesses and take a step away from the traditional process of visiting large jewelry stores, Etsy is the move.
Additionally, Etsy allows you the luxury of avoiding the sales rep trying to get you to buy the biggest, most expensive ring. You hold all of the control when shopping for engagement rings on Etsy.
How much do Etsy engagement rings cost?
The amount an Etsy engagement ring costs is really dependent on your budget. Etsy has thousands of online merchants, crafting jewelry with all different types of budgets in mind.
The beauty of Etsy is that you have full control of what you end up spending on an engagement ring. Since Etsy is an online marketplace, it’s super simple to adjust search settings to fit your budget perfectly.
You can select under $250 options, or adjust it to only see Etsy engagement rings that are over $1500. And since Etsy has so many jewelers, the difficult part won’t be finding a ring in your budget. The only challenge is choosing from the expanse of options, so make sure to give yourself enough time to browse.
How to Vet Etsy Engagement Ring Sellers
Some people have hesitations about buying a ring online due to the detached nature of the transaction. This is why it’s so important to vet your Etsy engagement ring seller before purchasing a ring on Etsy.
Once you’ve found a ring that you feel is the one, you’ll need to complete a deep dive through their reviews. Have other people bought rings from this seller and been happy? Or do you find a ton of complaints?
Also, check the jeweler’s exchange or refund policy, their general ratings, as well as their certifications. This is especially crucial if you’re looking for a certified diamond ring because you’ll want to ensure it’s legit.
Once you’ve verified that everything looks good, message the seller. A trustworthy vendor should be responsive and answer any questions you might have, rather than leaving you in the dark about a huge investment.
If the Etsy seller seems to check all of the boxes above, then you should be good to go! Just make sure to place the order in enough time to accommodate shipping delays or complete any necessary sizing adjustments, because you want to be fully prepared for the proposal!
We’re loving this triangular salt and pepper diamond Etsy engagement ring!
The unique dark center stone and complementary diamond band make this a fresh and modern vibe, perfect for the special someone that likes to rock an eclectic look.
This pear-shaped diamond ring is all we can think about because, I mean, look at it!
We can’t decide if it’s the stunning center stone or unique diamond accents that make this one of our favorites, but you can catch this ring in our Etsy cart soon.
Matte center stones always look so dreamy, and this pink-colored matte Etsy engagement ring is no exception.
Not only is the center stone super unique, but the twig brand band adds even more charm to this stunning ring.
GWS is always down to dive into modern wedding trends, which is why we’re all about this black quartz Art Deco-inspired ring.
This ring screams quality-made, as can be seen in the detailed diamond accents and intricate infinity band.
Fall in love with the mesmerizing hues of this bezel set aquamarine Etsy engagement ring.
Perfect for those that embrace simplistic beauty, we love this ring because it’s equally modern as it is timeless.
Love the classic look of oval? Check out our helpful oval engagement rings guide to see more just like the one above!
There isn’t anything boring about this fun and flirty turquoise diamond ring.
As much as we love this ring for its opulent turquoise center stone, we’re also obsessed with the classic halo diamond accents that create a floral-inspired aesthetic.
Do you love to make a statement? If so, we have the perfect Etsy engagement ring for you.
While the black quartz center stone is obviously eye-catching, add the starburst diamond halo and you have yourself a truly one-of-a-kind proposal.
Reminiscent of a walk through Irish fields, we’re obsessed with this Etsy engagement ring because of its charmingly eclectic style and hypnotic green center stone.
Braided bands always add a lovely touch, which is why this ring is one of our all-time favorites. Such a distinct look!
This celestial engagement ring made our list because it’s simply perfect for the loved one who shoots for the stars.
Also, can we please talk about how cool these moons and star diamond accents are? So unexpected and gorgeous.
Sometimes you just don’t feel like going with a diamond, which we love (in fact, we’ve basically written the guide to the best gemstone bands).
We’re recommending this stunning rose quartz ring because its style and center stone are an elegant yet classic take on an engagement ring.
If you love modern design but also enjoy classic details, this hexagonal Etsy engagement ring is a perfect choice.
From the bold center stone to the six diamond accents, this is an altogether great ring, with true geometric flair.
Another great option for those who want to ditch a diamond, we love this moss agate ring because of its fun colors and intricate detailing.
Plus, the half diamond halo is the perfect compliment to the mesmerizing center stone. This ring will have you believing in love at first sight.
If you loved ring #2 but thought, “Hmm…I’d rather have a rounder shape”, then we have the Etsy engagement ring for you!
The four prongs, as well as the luminescent center stone, have us obsessed with this morganite engagement ring.
As much as we love simplistic styles here at GWS, we also have room in our heart for statement rings such as this pearl and diamond band.
The yellow gold band, as well as the meticulously placed gemstones, are a jaw-dropping testament to craftsmanship. This ring feels like it came from a bygone era, in the best kind of way.
THAT. ASYMMETRICAL. DESIGN. Do you love this morganite ring? Because we do.
Considering the scattered diamond accents as well as the pear-shaped center stone, you’re looking at some elegantly beautiful Etsy engagement rings.
Here at GWS, we’re kind of obsessed with sapphire center stones, and their rich and dreamy blue hues.
Adding in the gorgeousness of the diamond halo and gold band, then we have to admit this ring is nothing short of perfection.
Get your vows ready because this ring will have your loved one running to the aisle with joy. We love the romantic look of the halo on this band and the way the yellow gold frames the tiny round cut stones. So romantic!
This Etsy engagement ring has us wanting to plan a scenic beachside wedding.
The raw-cut aquamarine stones, as well as the unique gold band, create a genuinely gorgeous design. A stunningly coastal look we’re totally obsessed with.
We at GWS love solitaire rings because they allow the center stone to do the talking.
As soon as you check out this solitaire marquise ring, you’ll be daydreaming about the wedding day in no time.
Love is a wonderland, and in order to take the next step, you might need this “Alice” aquamarine ring.
The dreamy center stone and stunning diamond accents make this Etsy engagement ring an adventure worth waiting for.
This black rutilated quartz is as effortlessly alternative as it is timelessly fun. Because this ring is so unique, your loved one is bound to impress and delight with every sight.
Dare to make a statement with this bold and beautiful hexagonal diamond ring set.
From the diamond crown band to the statement diamond accents, we love these Etsy engagement rings. It’s hard not to become obsessed with their gorgeously geometric design.
Because your significant other deserves the best, you need to choose a royalty-level ring. And this ring is a lovely choice that checks all the boxes!
Coming in a salt and pepper band set, these Etsy engagement rings are nothing short of regal.
This galaxy-inspired diamond ring is bound to sweep your loved one off their feet, whether there’s gravity or not.
The pearl shaped diamond reminds us of the night sky at the same time as the star-gazing diamond accents. Wait for a starry night to pop the question, and you’re destined for an out-of-this-world proposal.
Perfect for those that love the bold and the beautiful, this regal morganite Etsy engagement ring is stunning perfection.
From the diamond infinity band to the iridescent morganite stone, we’re obsessed with every inch of this pretty pink band.
This dainty diamond ring is a great choice for those who love effortless elegance. It’s the perfect blend of boho and celestial.
Easily pairing with other cherished rings and bands, this Etsy engagement ring is one of our all-time favorites.
Here at GWS, we don’t kiss and tell, so we’re obsessed with this secret heart aquamarine ring.
The round diamond, perfect halo accent, and gold band make this Etsy engagement ring an instant heirloom.
We’re roaring over this Art Deco-inspired round diamond Etsy engagement ring.
The intricate diamond halo and the stunning gold band make this ring a great choice for those that love a timeless look with a nod to eras past.
Beauty is often found in the little details, which is why we can’t get over this stunning solitaire topaz ring.
The thin gold band, combined with the beautiful topaz stone create a beautiful union, just like your future marriage.
These green beryl Etsy engagement rings are as stunning as they are eclectically rare. You’re not likely going to find a ring that looks identical to this one.
There’s something about pearls that simply exude elegance and this Akoya pearl Etsy engagement ring is taking our breath away.
The pearl center stone and mix of diamond and pearl accents will have you down on one knee as soon as you receive the package.
This 3.51 carat radiant cut engagement ring is a marvelously majestic choice, perfect for a truly glamorous proposal.
Glimmering and dazzling in any lighting, this ring will steal glances every day from your engagement day to your future wedding anniversaries.
It’s hard to choose just one favorite feature of this mother of pearl style diamond ring, but we have no complaints.
The stunning center stone and unique accent details make this Etsy engagement ring truly exceptional.
This lovely pavé ring is a beautiful design for a beautiful marriage. Especially with those gorgeous marquise and round cut accent stones hugging the sides of that tilted quartz center stone.
Boasting conflict-free and radiant cut diamonds, this beauty is the perfect way to launch a stunning new stage of your relationship.
Another throwback favorite, this Art Deco-inspired ring is the last but certainly not least favorite Etsy engagement ring we’re loving lately.
A black pear-shaped diamond, vintage-inspired detailing, and alternative design make this ring a stunning choice.
Need More Ring Inspiration and Planning Advice?
Love these Etsy engagement rings and need more ring inspo in your life?! We’ve got you covered. We have the prettiest list of budget-friendly rings, all under $1000.
Think diamonds aren’t for you? We’ve compiled the ultimate list of the prettiest gemstone engagement bands. It’s a can’t miss! We also have roundups on all things emeralds, sapphires, and the epic diamond-alternative, moissanite.
Which of these Etsy engagement rings is your favorite? Let us know in the comments which of these beauties you fell in love with first!