17 Best Places to Buy Engagement Rings for Women – The Complete Guide

classic elegant Brilliant Earth best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Brilliant Earth

So you’ve found “the one” — your life partner, your ride or die, the straw to your berry — and you’re ready to pop the question. First: CONGRATULATIONS! Second: It’s time to choose your forever ring. So, to help you find the one for your one, we’ve rounded 17 of the best places to buy engagement rings for women.

There’s a lot that goes into choosing the perfect finger candy (it is meant to last a lifetime, after all!), and knowing the best places to buy engagement rings is an essential first step.

But we’re not stopping there. As your engagement ring gurus, we’re also here to answer all your burning questions about how to choose the engagement ring that puts even her Pinterest board to shame. So, let’s get into it!

Green Wedding Shoe’s product selections are curated by the editorial team. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no cost to you. Please consider shopping through our links if you would like to support GWS!

Should you buy engagement rings online?

Keyzar Jewelry dainty gold diamond ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Keyzar Jewelry

While it may not be traditional, buying womens engagement rings online has never been easier, more reliable, or as fun! We’re all about online shopping here at GWS, and engagement rings are no exception. In fact, some of the best places to buy engagement rings for women are completely online!

But, with so much at stake (aka: the dream ring and the dream proposal!), buying engagement rings online isn’t for everyone. So, we thought we’d break down the pros and cons to help you decide.

P.S. Most of the best places to buy engagement rings for women have both online and in-person services. So it really comes down to your preference!

  • Pros: Ring shopping online means endless options, a user-friendly experience, and never having to leave the comfort of your couch! Plus, some of the best places to buy engagement rings for women may only have storefronts in certain states (or countries), so shopping online means you don’t have to limit your search to just your area.
  • Cons: It can be hard to imagine the magical moment of getting down on one knee without seeing the physical ring in front of you. Luckily, tons of jewelers make it super easy to return or exchange engagement rings you’ve bought online, just in case it doesn’t feel like the one!

If you decide to go the online route, most of the best places to buy engagement rings for women have sizing services and experts to help you virtually. But we’ve also created this guide on how to measure your partner’s ring size at home to make it easier!

What to look for when buying engagement rings for women

collection of Diamond Nexus alternative diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Diamond Nexus

With so many styles and amazing places to buy engagement rings for women, it can seem impossible to narrow it down to that one perfect design. But don’t worry — we’ve got your back!

If you’re going the classic diamond route, we suggest starting with the 4 C’s: cut, color, clarity, and carat. This determines the quality of the diamond and how the industry creates diamond ratings (and certifies each diamond).

But, one of these C’s may be more important to you than another, so it really comes down to preference and budget!

Here at GWS, we’re also a big fan of alternative diamonds versus mined (or natural) diamonds. With the same look and quality as traditional diamonds, lab-grown diamonds tend to be more sustainable and typically more ethical. Plus, they’re better for your bank account!

These days, most of the best places to buy engagement rings offer both natural and lab-grown options — we love to see it!

round cut halo moissanite ring with halo style best places to buy engagement rings for women

Another great alternative to the classic diamond? Moissanite! It’s known for being even more brilliant and radiant than diamond, so it’s sure to stun.

While diamonds have earned their reputation as a girl’s best friend, they’re definitely not the only option. With the rise of more unique and personalized ceremonies, we’re also seeing more and more gemstone engagement bands, and we’re not mad about it! From elegant emerald designs to stunning sapphire styles, there’s a major case for ditching tradition and going the gemstone route.

Finally: the metal. Most ring settings are made with gold, whether traditional yellow gold, modern white gold (which resembles silver), or trendy rose gold.

You’ll also want to check whether the gold is 14k or 18k — a higher karat contains more gold and will appear brighter, but it’s also less durable to everyday wear and tear. And don’t sleep on platinum, one of the most durable precious metals guaranteed to last a lifetime!

How we’ve narrowed down our list of the best places to buy engagement rings for women

Marrow Fine gold bezel solitaire diamond ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Marrow Fine

Your ring shopping journey will be as unique as your love story — and that’s why we considered multiple factors when narrowing down the best places to buy engagement rings for women.

From the best places to buy sustainable engagement rings to the best places to buy non-traditional engagement rings to the best places to buy budget-friendly engagement rings for women, we’ve covered all the bases. So, if a specific factor is important to you, we’ve most likely included a retailer that specializes in it below!

(We even found the best place to buy engagement rings for women who LOVE The Bachelor!!)

Ready to put a ring on it? Keep scrolling for our top brands!

1. Diamond Nexus: Best Place to Buy Sustainable Engagement Rings for Women

Diamond Nexus marquise cut solitaire ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Diamond Nexus

We love a lot about Diamond Nexus engagement rings — they’re ensured for life, they come with complimentary resizing and easy exchanges, and they’re SO stunning!

But the main reason we chose this as one of the best places to buy engagement rings for women has to be their Nexus Diamond™ alternative. This patented lab-created stone looks identical to a diamond (minus the imperfections and high price tag of a diamond!). In other words, these stones are flawless, environmentally friendly, and cost up to 90% less than mined diamonds. Say less!

We love these ethical rings so much that we curated a list of our fave Diamond Nexus alternative rings for GWS ladies. Now, you only have to narrow it down to just one!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $850 – $2000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Work with a custom design expert from the brand’s sister company, Forever Artisans, to create a one-of-a-kind engagement ring that will last a lifetime.

Shipping Policy: Free shipping for US orders

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days

Shop These Diamond Nexus Best Engagement Rings For Women

2. Blue Nile: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Any Style and Price Range

Blue Nile halo diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Blue Nile

With a mix of trendy styles and timeless classics, Blue Nile has something for every woman — plus the option to design your dream ring. Talk about bringing your one-of-a-kind love story to life!

And, as the largest (and one of the best) places to buy engagement rings for women, you know you can trust Blue Nile. Whether you’re looking for budget-friendly engagement bands or a luxury heirloom piece, your forever finger candy is only a few scrolls away!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $200 – $99,000 (but most engagement rings fall within the $900 – $4,000 range)

Engagement Ring Customizability: Customize the setting and metal of any of Blue Nile’s womens ring styles, or design your perfect ring from scratch with the brand’s user-friendly custom platform.

Shipping Time: Free shipping in 1 -7 business days

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days

Shop Blue Nile’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

3. James Allen: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings Online

hand wearing a collection of James Allen classic round diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy engagement rings online: James Allen

If you love online shopping as much as we do, get ready to fall head over heels in love with James Allen!

One of the best places to buy engagement rings for women online, James Allen photographs each of their 500,000+ conflict-free diamonds in 360° HD. So you know exactly what you’re getting before it comes in the mail!

You’ll also have the option of real-time diamond inspections (all virtual) with diamond experts because choosing your dream engagement ring should be exciting, not stressful!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,600 – $100,000+ (depending on the diamond of your choice!)

Engagement Ring Customizability: You get to pick out your dream diamond from James Allen’s HUGE collection of stones, plus the setting you want to complement the sparkle. In other words, this is definitely one of the best places to buy a custom engagement ring!

Shipping Time: Free shipping in 1 – 2 days

Return Policy: Full refund within 30 days

Shop James Allen’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

4. Staghead Designs: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Boho Babes

Staghead Designs round salt and pepper ring with diamond accents best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Staghead Designs

With the motto “Wear & Be Wild,” Staghead Designs has the perfect engagement rings for free-spirited, unconventional couples. Did we mention we’re obsessed?!

All handcrafted using distinct and wild materials that are meaningful to you, Staghead Designs is one of the best places to buy engagement rings for women that are truly unlike anything else. Kind of like your love! All cheesiness aside, this is THE place for rustic designs (think: branch and antler bands), boho rings, and non-traditional stones.

We’re also suckers for Staghead’s rad and original collections, from the celestial line (because your love was written in the stars!) to their range of salt and pepper diamond rings!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $500 – $5,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Customize the stone and materials of any Staghead Designs engagement ring to make it more meaningful to you, or work with a designer to create your one-of-a-kind design.

Shipping Time: 1 – 8 weeks

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days (or a partial refund for custom orders)

Shop These Staghead Designs Best Engagement Rings For Women

collection of bohemian engagement rings

If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind ring for your love story, check out our list of the most dazzling, unique engagement bands!

5. Catbird: Best Place to Buy Dainty + Distinct Bands

Catbird solitaire diamond ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Catbird

Traditional rings not your jam? You can stop scrolling now — Catbird reigns supreme when it comes to original styles that you won’t find anywhere else!

We’re absolutely smitten with Catbird’s dainty designs, and as a bonus, they’re all made with recycled materials and hand-finished in the brand’s Brooklyn studio. We love a ring with a story!

Plus, gorgeous engagement rings for women are just the tip of the iceberg for what Catbird offers. They also provide virtual styling sessions (to help you make your proposal as perfect as you’ve always imagined), a home try-on kit with sample rings, and the option to get zapped (it’s as cool as it sounds)!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $900 – $13,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: While Catbird doesn’t offer custom rings, they do provide both virtual and in-person ring consultations with an expert.

Shipping Time: Same day shipping for $30, 1-day shipping for $25, or 2-day shipping for $5

Return Policy: Full refund within 10 days

Shop Catbird’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

6. Kay Jewelers: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Women Who Are The Bachelor Fans

Kay Jewelers gold diamond halo ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Kay Jewelers

With over 100 years of history, Kay Jewelers knows a thing or two about love and the jewelry that represents it. That’s why they’re one of the best places to buy engagement rings for women that are all about sparkle, shine, and mega diamonds.

From dazzling double halo designs to chic + classic round diamond rings, Kay has the best of the best.

They even have their own line of Neil Lane rings — you know, the same designer that creates the engagement rings for The Bachelor couples. We’re not fangirling, you are!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $500 – $23,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: You can create your custom engagement ring not only at Kay Jewelers but also at Neil Lane!

Shipping Time: 3 – 5 business days

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days or exchanges within 60 days

Shop Kay Jeweler’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

7. Etsy: Best Place to Buy Affordable Handmade Designs

three stone dainty ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: RosadosBox on Etsy

For stunning, Pinterest-worthy designs that won’t break the bank, look no further than Etsy! In addition to traditional rings, many of their independent designers keep costs low with moissanite engagement bands — an ethical and budget-friendly gem that is a brilliant alternative to diamonds.

But despite being on the more affordable side, their collection of the best engagement rings for women packs MAJOR style. We love their delicate and romantic rings just as much as we love their non-traditional and bold designs!

You can also rest assured of the quality of each handmade ring thanks to the thousands of reviews from other buyers!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $50 – $2,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Since Etsy is made up of independent designers, each ring (and design process) is totally unique — but most do offer options for customization, from engraving to different stone choices.

Shipping Time: Shipping depends on the designer, but typically 2 days – 2 weeks

Return Policy: This also depends on the designer, but you can usually expect free returns within 7 – 14 days

Shop Etsy’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

pear shaped rosey diamond etsy engagement band

Do you love Etsy as much as we do?! Then don’t miss our list of the best Etsy engagement bands for every style!

8. Brilliant Earth: Best Place to Buy Ethical Engagement Rings for Women

Brilliant Earth gold multi-stone diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Brilliant Earth

Modern, timeless, and sustainable? Sign us up! Brilliant Earth‘s collection of the best engagement rings for women is all about blending an ethical approach to jewelry-making with designs that never go out of style.

They use Beyond Conflict FreeTM Diamonds, plus recycled gold, so you can feel good about rocking a ring that looks good. Even their ring boxes use sustainable packaging!

And if that wasn’t enough, Brilliant Earth also has another feature we can’t stop obsessing over: their virtual try-on experience! Just upload a picture of your hand, then test out different styles and stacks — all while never leaving your couch.

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $450 – $6,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Customize every aspect of your womens engagement ring right on Brilliant Earth’s website, from the setting to the diamonds to the smallest hidden details.

Shipping Time: Shipping is free, but the timing will depend on your individual order

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days

Shop Brilliant Earth’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

9. Capucinne: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Creative Women

Capucinne moss agate gold rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement rings: Capucinne

Introducing: one of our favorite places for stunning alternative engagement bands! Capucinne is one of the best places to buy gemstone engagement rings for women packed with creativity, personality, and intrigue.

If those words could also be used to describe you (or your soon-to-be betrothed), then you may have just found your perfect fit! A match made in heaven for those who don’t like to follow the crowd and instead want a forever ring that feels like them.

But be warned — Capucinne has SO many impressive womens ring styles you may not be able to choose just one!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $850 – $10,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: According to Capucinne, the “C” in their name also stands for “custom.” Each of their imaginative engagement rings can be customized as much or as little as you want — and you can also collaborate with their designers to create a truly one-of-a-kind custom piece!

Shipping Time: Free shipping in 2 – 10 business days

Return Policy: Full refund within 5 days, excluding custom orders

Shop Capuccine’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

10. Keyzar: Best Place to Buy Custom Made-to-Order Designs

Keyzar round distinct solitaire ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Keyzar

While most of the jewelers on this list offer customization for their engagement rings, Keyzar really takes it to the next level. Each ring is made to order, so you know you’re getting a piece that’s 100% your own.

The best part? It only takes two easy steps to get your one-of-a-kind engagement ring! First, choose your setting from a massive catalog of stunning options, then pick a diamond (using virtual 360° filters) to complete the look, and voila! You’re ready to become an ~engaged~ couple.

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,200 – $28,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Keyzar is definitely one of the best places to buy custom engagement rings for women, with each piece made to order to your specifications!

Shipping Time: Free shipping in 1 – 2 days

Return Policy: Free returns within 30 days

Shop Keyzar’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

11. Marrow Fine: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings for Modern Women

Marrow Fine stackable glamorous gold diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy modern engagement rings for women: Marrow Fine

Bookmark! Screenshot! Pin! That is the only correct response to Marrow Fine‘s ultra glam collection of womens engagement rings.

With unexpected styles (like trendy toi et moi engagement bands) that we can’t help but ooh and ahh over, these rings are made for the most glamorous, bold, and modern women. Because you deserve a rock that sparkles as much as you do!

We also LOVE how Marrow Fine’s engagement rings for women are super stackable, so you can add on to your heirloom-worthy look for the big day and beyond!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,500 – $60,000 (but most engagement rings fall within the $5,000 – $11,000 range)

Engagement Ring Customizability: Marrow Fine started with the founder, Jillian Sassone, reworking heirloom rings to create something even more special — so the brand is no stranger to customizations! Whether you’re starting from an idea or breathing new life into an heirloom piece, their designers are here to help make your dreams a reality.

Shipping Time: Next day or 2-day delivery

Return Policy: No refunds, but exchanges within 10 days

Shop Marrow Fine’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

12. Kinn: Best Place to Buy Heirloom-Worthy Engagement Rings for Women

Kinn distinct gold ribbed ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy heirloom engagement rings for women: Kinn

There’s something so special about buying a piece of jewelry that you know will be passed down for generations. And the best place to buy heirloom-quality engagement rings for women has to be Kinn!

Let’s break down what makes Kinn so unique: not only do they use sustainable materials, but they also develop and manufacture their pieces from start to finish right in Los Angeles.

And, most importantly, their bespoke womens engagement rings are simply TO DIE FOR! With distinct designs that will stay in style for multiple generations, Kinn definitely has rings worthy of your vows.

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,000 – $6,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Kinn will help you design a swoon-worthy engagement ring from scratch so you can pack your promise full of meaning and symbolism!

Shipping Time: 2 – 7 business days

Return Policy: Returns within 10 days

Shop Kinn’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

13. Clean Origin: Best Place to Buy Clean Lab Grown Stones

Clean Origin Deco inspired lab grown diamond halo ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy ethical engagement rings: Clean Origin

With 100% lab grown diamonds, Clean Origin is one of the best places to buy engagement rings for women that are 100% ethical.

(P.S. If you’re worried that lab grown diamonds aren’t as good as mined diamonds, don’t be! They’re still real diamonds, and they have tons of additional benefits, too!)

Like the couples they serve, Clean Origin’s rings come in all shapes and sizes. We’re talking elegant oval engagement bands, dazzling art deco rings, and so, so much more!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $500 – $4,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Design your own Clean Origin engagement ring from scratch by choosing your setting, stone, and distinct details!

Shipping Time: Free 2-day shipping

Return Policy: Return within 100 days

Shop Clean Origin’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

14. Taylor & Hart: Best Place to Buy Engagement Rings That Bring Your Love Story to Life

Taylor & Hart distinct green baguette cut and diamond ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy memorable engagement rings: Taylor & Hart

Prepare for all your other jewelry to be jealous once they see Taylor & Hart‘s engagement rings! One of the best places to buy engagement rings if you want to get the London look, Taylor & Hart designs bespoke rings for your bespoke story all the way from across the pond.

What we love about Taylor & Hart is that they take the time to get to know you before designing your lifetime ring. Their approach is heartfelt and hands-on, and we are here. for. it.

As a sweet bonus, each womens engagement ring is finished with a signature ruby nestled in the band. Just a little way for the designer to say congrats!!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,400 – $14,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Totally bespoke, each of Taylor & Hart’s engagement rings is customized based on your love story, so you can design a ring that’s totally your own!

Shipping Time: Shipping within 30 days

Return Policy: Returns and exchanges within 90 days

Shop Taylor & Hart’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

collection of boho green stone engagement bands

Is your dream ring trendy and timeless at the same time? Then you’re going to LOVE these swoon-worthy emerald engagement bands!

15. VRAI: Best Place to Buy Celebrity-Approved Designs

VRAI glamorous gold diamond rings best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place to buy celebrity-approved engagement rings: VRAI

Spotted: Hailey Bieber, Camila Cabello, Shakira, Joe Jonas, Jennifer Lopez, and Kendall Jenner have all been seen wearing VRAI’s lab grown diamonds. And if it’s good enough for J.Lo, then it’s definitely good enough for us!

One of the best places to buy luxury engagement rings for women that are also ethical and sustainable, VRAI is definitely top tier (and so are their chic + minimalistic designs!). It’s no wonder the brand is a celebrity favorite!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1,600 – $26,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Pick out your favorite setting and diamond, or get VRAI’s white glove experience to design something all your own!

Shipping Time: 2 business days

Return Policy: Full refund within 30 days

Shop VRAI’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

16. Stone and Strand: Best Woman-Owned Place to Buy Engagement Rings

Stone and Strand round diamond ring with side baguette stones best places to buy engagement rings for women
best woman-owned place to buy engagement rings: Stone and Strand

When it comes to the best places to buy engagement rings for women, it’s safe to say that women know best. And that’s why we’re big fans of Stone and Strand, one of the best woman-owned places to buy engagement rings for women!

There’s nothing better than rings that are designed for women by women — except maybe a brand that also works to empower women and give them some timeless glitz and glam! (Just peep Stone and Strand’s rad Good Girl Mission to see what we mean.)

A fun detail: each one of Stone and Strand’s engagement rings is named after a woman. We especially love the Clara ring and the Jacqueline ring!

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $750 – $13,700

Engagement Ring Customizability: With Stone and Strand’s Bespoke Bridal collection, you can customize your setting, cut, and carat weight for their most stunning heirloom-worthy rings!

Shipping Time: 7 – 10 business days

Return Policy: Returns within 100 days

Shop Stone and Strand’s Best Engagement Rings For Women

17. Rêve Diamonds: Best Place for Personal Service

Reve Diamonds best places to buy engagement rings for women
best place for personal service to buy engagement rings: Rêve Diamonds

Rêve Diamonds was founded on the ethos of providing customers with premium quality diamonds at unrivaled prices, supported by exceptional customer service where the customer always comes first. Based in New York City, their store – which has an extensive inventory of over 30,000 premium quality loose diamonds! – allows them to offer wholesale prices to their customers.

With enough sparkle to last a lifetime, the Rêve Diamonds collection takes classic designs and gives them a glamorous upgrade. The result? Rings that ooze luxury.

And once you’ve picked out your perfect engagement ring, you’ll also want to check out the brand’s other gorgeous jewelry collections, from diamond pendant necklaces to tennis bracelets.

Price Range for Engagement Rings for Women: $1400 – $40,000

Engagement Ring Customizability: Go completely custom with the help of the Rêve Diamonds team — and, as one of the best places for personal service for your engagement rings for women, they’ll also help you achieve a full luxe + custom big day look!

Shipping Time: Your diamond jewelry is made to your exact specifications. This means some pieces can take longer than others. They generally aim to deliver your items within 2-14 days of receiving your order.

Return Policy: They offer a 30-day return policy.

Shop These Rêve Diamonds Best Engagement Rings For Women

We’ve Covered The Best Places to Buy The Ring. Now It’s Time to Plan The Proposal.

Staghead Designs distinct topaz halo ring best places to buy engagement rings for women
women’s engagement ring: Staghead Designs

Now that you’re an expert on the best places to buy engagement rings, you can start planning one of the magical moments of your life: popping the question!

To make it a moment you’ll never forget, don’t miss our list of 74 unique proposal ideas guaranteed to cause some (happy) tears!

And, before you finish up your ring shopping, be sure to check out our ultimate guide to how to measure ring size. We have expert tips on how to do this secretly so the proposal can stay a surprise!

Which of these best places to buy womens engagement rings was your favorite? And how are you choosing your forever ring? Let us know in the comments below!

Explore: